Neither pure socialism, nor pure capitalism [can] exist; why the outcry about Obama’s “virtual”-socialism?

 

Prologue:                                                                                                                                Those interested in the topic of this blog which deals with the facts that Capitalism, as is Socialism, in their pure states, cannot survive within sovereign human societies, should also avail themselves of:               

This blog, Part II: Why is it not possible for either purs Socialism or pure Capitalism to survive?

or

Pure Capitalism means anarchy, while pure Socialism means Chaos!

The issue: Since neither pure socialism, nor pure capitalism [can] exist; why the outcry about Obama’s [virtual]-socialism? The outcry about what many spoke-persons for US conservatives label: European Socialism?

Conservative media voices, such as Hannity, Limbaugh, O’Reilly, Beck, Ingel, Coulter, to name a few, keep telling their audiences that socialism never worked. What they fail to tell their audiences is that neither did capitalism. As a matter of fact, one cannot identify an economic system that endured without including socialistic elements, or without undergoing major changes, throughout the history of civilization.

Some economies have been around and prospered for a few years, they were (a few still are) generally a hybrid operations adopting principals from one system or another, when it deemed advisable. There are a number of capitalistic countries (such as Canada, and perhaps Sweden) that boast national, or socialistic health care systems. Their systems may not be perfect, but they are clearly not inferior the the US system, and they do not leave out tens of millions of their citizen without any health resources.

United States capitalism, the great success, that it appeared to be from time to time, had major failures (such as the great dipression, and the situation we are in today;) that notwithstanding, it also deploys socialistic elements to simply allow it to function. Labor unions, the small amount of income re-distribution in the tax code, and welfare, are but three examples, there are many more, none are necessarily destructive items to degrade capitalism, to the contrary, they usually enhance the way economies operate.

Conservatives should not fear Obama for socialistic elements that he may introduce in his policies; if they chose to criticize the President, they should do so on the merit of each item they don’t like, not because they could attach the socialism label to it!


As lacking as it is, Stimulus desrves a chance!

Conservatives on the right are quite sure, or so they say, that the Democratic stimulus package will not work. Most of the pundits on the right suggest that the economy package will not work mostly because it is socialistic and socialism does not work. The argument moves on to suggest that only capitalism works, a position that today’s economy, and history, do not support,

 

Most of the conservative spokespeople point back the Ronald Reagan times as a sample of successful capitalism, they all seem to forget that before Reagan left office the economy started to slide. The economic downturn, which was attributed to trickle-down-economics, prompted David Stockman, who initiated the system, to acknowledge that it did not work.  

 

Not only is it wrong to suggest that only capitalism works, it is wrong to suggest that a pure capitalistic system, one without elements of socialism, and perhaps even feudalism, ever existed, or can ever exist. 

 

To reject the present stimulus package because it contains element of socialism, is foolhardy, and shortsighted. And to suggest that giving people money to people who do not pay taxes is socialism, demonstrates a blatant twisting of facts, and conveniently misrepresenting the meaning of reasonably well-defined terms, to make a case where there may not be one.

 

The stimulus package may include elements of socialism, or borrow from the socialistic theory, but it is neither pure socialism, any more than it is capitalism. The package feeds into a quasi-socialistic, or a quasi capitalistic system, you pick your choice.

 

Our intent is not to say that the presently proposed stimulus package will work; our desire is to suggest that it deserves a chance, and that by given a chance, it may well solve, or at least reduce, the present economic disaster that was left the Obama Administration to resolve.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.